Unsolved Episodes

June 15, 2022

2019: The Unsolved Case of Jessica McCormack

This is not a typical ONUC episode. A friend of Jessica McCormack reached out to us asked if we could do anything to spread awareness of their friend's unsolved murder. Kayla spoke with Jessica's friend and looked more into t...

Episode page
Feb. 21, 2022

1838: The Mystery of 'The Beautiful Cigar Girl' Mary Cecilia Rogers

A body is found in the Hudson River. Four years earlier a newspaper falsely reported a woman missing. What happened to Mary Cecilia Rogers? This week the ONUC gals discuss the mysterious death of Mary Cecilia Rogers, the men ...

Episode page
Jan. 3, 2022

1832: The Duffy's Cut Railroad Murders

We ended 2021 with no murder and start 2022 with 57. Leah was not happy. This week the ONUC gals discuss the unexplained death of 57 Irish Catholic immigrants, the gals dig into their theories for the case, and discuss …

Episode page
Nov. 22, 2021

1826: The Disappearance of William Morgan

What are the freemasons? Are they really as powerful as some think? What do they have to do with the disappearance of William Morgan? Everything. This week the ONUC gals discuss the disappearance of William Morgan, an anti-fr...

Episode page
Sept. 6, 2021

1815: The Disappearance of the USS Epervier

How many US Navy ships are missing or presumed lost? Where they all swept away by a hurricane? Or is there something much more mysterious to blame? This week the ONUC gals discuss the disappearance of the USS Epervier. Join …

Episode page
Aug. 2, 2021

1810: The Amish Murder Mystery

'Just because it walks like a duck, and talks like a duck, doesn't make it a Solomon.' This week the ONUC gals cover the 'Amish Murder Mystery', Amish culture, a semi deathbed confession, and the meaning of an 'incel'. Trigge...

Episode page
July 26, 2021

1809: The Mysterious Death of Meriwether Lewis

Meriwether Lewis. One of the most recognized names in United States History. The Lewis and Clark Expedition. Governor of Upper Louisiana. Relative to Thomas Jefferson. Why would a man as influential to the nation chose to end...

Episode page
May 31, 2021

1802: The Life and Disappearance of Dr. James Durham

How do stories like this fall through the cracks? This week the ONUC gals discuss the inspiring life of Dr. James Durham and what could have caused the first black doctor in United States history to disappear. Trigger Warning...

Episode page
May 31, 2021

1801: Elizabeth Fales and Jason Fairbanks

A man staggers toward you holding a knife, covered in blood, and tells you someone is dead. Would you think he did it? On this episode, the ONUC gals discuss the 'happy' couple Elizabeth Fales and Jason Fairbanks. Were they …

Episode page