Nov. 22, 2021

1826: The Disappearance of William Morgan

What are the freemasons? Are they really as powerful as some think? What do they have to do with the disappearance of William Mor…

Episode page
Nov. 15, 2021

1825: The Beauchamp-Sharp Tragedy

Murder in a passionate rage is one that is heard in many stories. A jilted lover is pushed over the edge to insanity and murders …

Episode page
Nov. 8, 2021

1824: The Fall Creek Massacre

It's an event that led to another first in the nation. An event that should have never taken place. A senseless act only brought …

Episode page
Nov. 1, 2021

1823: The Sheriff's Mistress

Man meets woman. Man marries woman. Life was perfect... until it wasn't. This week the ONUC gals discuss the events in 1823, the …

Episode page
Oct. 25, 2021

1822: The Manhattan Burial Crisis

HAPPY HALLOWEEN! The biggest outbreak of yellow fever in Manhattan's history, so many people to bury that gravediggers can't keep…

Episode page
Oct. 18, 2021

1821: The Wrongful Murder of Accused Witch, Kau-Qua-Tau

What is a witch? Are they really the much different from some of the religions we know today? The real question of the week is...…

Episode page
Oct. 11, 2021

1820: Lavinia Fisher AKA America's First Female Serial Killer (Maybe)

Lavinia Fisher has an impressive laundry list of titles from highwaywoman, serial killer ... and ghost? But, how many of those ar…

Episode page
Oct. 4, 2021

1819: The Wrongful Murder Conviction of the Boorn Brothers

Some people become famous when they die, but how do you become famous simply because you're alive? This week the ONUC gals discus…

Episode page
Sept. 27, 2021

1818: America's First Murder For Hire Case

What do you get when you cross a last will and testament, profitable land, and three men fighting over it? One man dead, four sen…

Episode page
Sept. 20, 2021

1817: America's First Public Enemy No. 1

Have you or someone you love ever skipped school? Did your parents think you were possessed by demons as a child? Most importantl…

Episode page
Sept. 13, 2021

1816: America's First Case of Murder by Counseling

TRIGGER WARNING EPISODE This week's episode has heavy discussion of suicide. If that is a subject that you are not able to hear o…

Episode page
Sept. 6, 2021

1815: The Disappearance of the USS Epervier

How many US Navy ships are missing or presumed lost? Where they all swept away by a hurricane? Or is there something much more my…

Episode page
Aug. 30, 2021

1814: The Stories of John Lewis & Mary Antoine

What do you get when you cross the only US citizen to die in the burning of Washington D.C. and a woman who murders her ex-boyfri…

Episode page
Aug. 23, 2021

1813: Sally Hamilton and Murderer's Creek

We're going to the Catskills! This week the ONUC gals discuss the history of the Catskill Mountains, how Murderer's Creek got its…

Episode page
Aug. 16, 2021

1812: Chicago's First Murder

' Welcome, Ladies and Gentlemen, you are about to see a story of murder, greed, corruption, violence, exploitation, adultery, and…

Episode page
Aug. 9, 2021

1811: The Murder of George

*In this episode, there is some slight background noise. The podcast mascots (Fletcher, Claire, and Nox) are the culprits and the…

Episode page
Aug. 2, 2021

1810: The Amish Murder Mystery

'Just because it walks like a duck, and talks like a duck, doesn't make it a Solomon.' This week the ONUC gals cover the 'Amish M…

Episode page
July 26, 2021

1809: The Mysterious Death of Meriwether Lewis

Meriwether Lewis. One of the most recognized names in United States History. The Lewis and Clark Expedition. Governor of Upper Lo…

Episode page
July 19, 2021

1808: America's First Murder Ballad

It's a tale as old as time. Man loves woman. Woman loves man. Man finds another woman. Man then kills first woman. Sounds pretty …

Episode page
July 12, 2021

1807: The Man Who Was Hanged Twice

If a tree falls in Genesee County, New York, can anyone hear it? We aren't sure. But, if you cut it down you might get murdered f…

Episode page
July 5, 2021

1806: The Purrington Family Massacre

The Purrington family seemed to have it all from the outside looking in. But, there were troubles lurking beneath the surface. In…

Episode page
June 28, 2021

1805: Dominic Daley and James Halligan

Two Irishmen are walking down a road... sounds like the beginning of a joke right? In this episode, the ONUC gals cover the murde…

Episode page
June 21, 2021

1804 Part 2: The Duel in Weehawken

Welcome to part two of our coverage on Alexander Hamilton, Aaron Burr, and the infamous duel in Weehawken! Stick around after the…

Episode page
June 14, 2021

1804 Part 1: The Duel in Weehawken

If ONUC covers 1804 without talking about Alexander Hamilton, then did ONUC even cover 1804? No. This is our FIRST two part episo…

Episode page